MG Comet EV vs Tata Punch EV — Which One Should You Buy?
Last updated 24 July 2026
Quick Verdict
Tata Punch EV wins on both range and value — the clear pick.
MG Comet EV
MG
Comet EV
₹7.49 L
Range: 150 km
Battery: 17.3 kWh
Top: 100 km/h
Charge: — min
Tata Punch EV
Tata
Punch EV
₹9.99 L
Range: 230 km
Battery: 25 kWh
Top: 140 km/h
Charge: 56 min
Detailed Specifications
| Spec | MG Comet EV | Tata Punch EV |
|---|---|---|
| Price (ex-showroom) | ₹7.49 L | ₹9.99 L |
| Battery | 17.3 kWh | 25 kWh |
| Real-world range | 150 km | 230 km |
| ARAI/MIDC range | 230 km | 315 km |
| Top speed | 100 km/h | 140 km/h |
| 0-100 km/h | 13s | 9.5s |
| Motor power | 30 kW | 60 kW |
| Motor torque | 110 Nm | 114 Nm |
| DC fast charge (10-80%) | Not supported | 56 min |
| AC charging | 7 hr | 5 hr |
| Drivetrain | RWD | FWD |
| Seating | 4 seats | 5 seats |
| Boot space | — | 366 L |
| Ground clearance | 165 mm | 190 mm |
| Battery warranty | 8 years | 8 years |
| NCAP rating | Untested | 5★ |
Cells highlighted in green indicate the best value in that row.
Variants Available
MG Comet EV
- • Pace
- • Play
- • Plush
Tata Punch EV
- • Smart
- • Adventure
- • Empowered+
Key Features
MG Comet EV
- ✓ Dual 10.25" screens
- ✓ Connected app
- ✓ Compact urban
Tata Punch EV
- ✓ V2L
- ✓ 10.25" infotainment
- ✓ Cruise control
- ✓ Auto AC
Which is better for…?
Daily city commute
Tata Punch EV
Tata Punch EV squeezes ~9.2 km per kWh — the most efficient here, ideal for stop-go traffic.
Highway long-distance
Tata Punch EV
Tata Punch EV balances 230 km of range with 140 km/h top speed — best highway combo.
Family use
Tata Punch EV
Tata Punch EV combines 5-seat capacity, 366L boot, and 5★ safety.
Tight budget
MG Comet EV
MG Comet EV at ₹7.49 L is the most wallet-friendly choice.
Long-term ownership
MG Comet EV
MG Comet EV ships with a 8-year battery warranty.
Pros & Cons
MG Comet EV
Pros
- + Cheapest 4-seater EV
- + Easy to park
- + Great as 2nd car
Cons
- − No DC fast charging
- − Tiny boot
- − Not for highways
Tata Punch EV
Pros
- + Affordable
- + 5-star Global NCAP
- + SUV stance
Cons
- − Smaller battery
- − Modest top speed
Final Verdict
Tata Punch EV wins on both range and value — the clear pick.
- Better real-world range: Tata Punch EV — Tata Punch EV delivers ~230 km vs 150 km.
- Better value (₹/km of range): Tata Punch EV — Tata Punch EV costs ~₹4,343 per km of range — the lowest of the lot.
- Better DC fast charging: Tata Punch EV — Tata Punch EV hits 10→80% in 56 min.
- Better safety: Tata Punch EV — Tata Punch EV scores 5★ NCAP.
- Better performance: Tata Punch EV — Tata Punch EV hits 100 km/h in 9.5s.
- Most affordable: MG Comet EV — Starts at ₹7.49 L — ₹2.50 L cheaper than the priciest here.